Loan consolidation: when combining loans saves money
When one new loan to close several saves money, the tenure trap, and why consolidation and settlement have opposite effects on your credit record.
Loan consolidation means taking one new loan to close several old ones, so you pay one EMI instead of three or four. It saves money only when the new loan's rate is clearly lower than what you pay now, the closing costs are small, and you don't stretch the repayment over many more months. Get any of those wrong and it costs more, even while the EMI looks smaller. Here's how to tell which way it goes, with the sums.
When consolidation helps
- High-rate debt. Credit card balances, card EMIs and some consumer loans often cost 24% to 40% a year. Moving them to a personal loan at a lower rate cuts the interest.
- Too many due dates. One EMI is easier to manage, and every missed payment hurts your credit score.
- A cash squeeze. A lower EMI can stop you missing payments. That's worth something even if the total cost is a little higher, as long as you know it.
When it doesn't
- A longer tenure. The most common trap. Spreading the same debt over more months lowers the EMI and raises the total interest.
- Closing costs. Your old lender may charge for closing a fixed-rate loan early, and the new one charges a processing fee. Both carry GST.
- A small rate gap. Moving a 14% loan to 13% rarely covers the costs.
- Running the cards up again. If the cleared card fills back up, you have the new loan and the old debt.
Worked example: three loans into one
Here's an example with three loans and what's left on each today. The rates and charges are examples, not any lender's terms.
| Loan | Principal still owed | Rate | Months left | EMI | Interest still to pay |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Personal loan | ₹1,80,000 | 16% | 30 | ₹7,319 | ₹39,575 |
| Consumer durable loan | ₹40,000 | 24% | 10 | ₹4,453 | ₹4,531 |
| Credit card balance, cleared over 12 months | ₹60,000 | 36% | 12 | ₹6,028 | ₹12,333 |
| Total | ₹2,80,000 | ₹17,800 | ₹56,439 |
A new lender offers ₹2,80,000 at 13%. Closing costs: a 4% foreclosure charge on the personal loan (₹8,496 with GST) and a 2% processing fee on the new loan (₹6,608 with GST), ₹15,104 in all.
| New loan tenure | New EMI | Interest | Interest + closing costs | Compared with keeping the three |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 24 months | ₹13,312 | ₹39,481 | ₹54,585 | Saves ₹1,854 |
| 36 months | ₹9,434 | ₹59,635 | ₹74,739 | Costs ₹18,300 more |
| 48 months | ₹7,512 | ₹80,562 | ₹95,666 | Costs ₹39,227 more |
The 48-month option cuts your EMIs from ₹17,800 to ₹7,512, which feels like a win, but costs ₹39,227 more. Even the 24-month option barely saves, because the personal loan at 16% wasn't that expensive and closing it costs ₹8,496.
Example 2: consolidate only the expensive debt. Leave the personal loan alone. Move just the durable loan and the card balance, ₹1,00,000, to a new loan at 13% for 12 months with a 2% fee (₹2,360 with GST). The EMI for those two falls from ₹10,481 to ₹8,932, and the interest from ₹16,864 to ₹7,181. With the fee, you save ₹7,323.
That's the rule worth remembering: consolidate the expensive debt, not everything, and keep the tenure short. To try your own loans, the personal loan EMI calculator shows the EMI and total interest at any rate and tenure.
Consolidation is not settlement
The names sound alike; the effect on your credit record is the opposite.
- Consolidation: the old loans are paid in full by the new one and show as closed on your credit report. The new loan is a fresh account you repay normally.
- Settlement: the lender agrees to accept less than you owe. The account is reported as settled, which lenders read as a sign you couldn't repay in full, and it counts against later applications (CIBIL: impact of "settled" status). Paying the rest later and asking the lender to report the account as closed is the way back. Under RBI rules, a bank or NBFC that settles with you must wait at least 12 months before lending to you again, and its own policy can make it longer (RBI directions for banks, para 96; for NBFCs, para 95).
If someone offers to "settle" your loans for a fee, be careful: that damages your record, and paying a third party doesn't change what the lender reports. How to check whether a lender is genuine.
What it does to your credit score
Applying for the new loan adds an enquiry to your credit report. Closing several accounts and repaying the new one on time usually helps over time, especially if it brings your card balances down. Apply to one lender at a time. Why several applications close together hurt.
Before you apply
- List every loan and card balance with its rate, months left and any closing charge. Your loan statements and KFS have them.
- Get the new lender's APR, not just the rate. It's on the Key Fact Statement (what to check on it).
- Compare total interest plus costs, both ways, at the same or shorter tenure.
- Close the old accounts properly and get a no-dues letter for each.
- Keep the cleared cards for emergencies only, or lower their limits.
The loan foreclosure calculator shows what closing one loan early costs and saves, and the balance transfer calculator compares an old loan with a new one.
Frequently asked questions
Does debt consolidation hurt my CIBIL score?
The new application adds one enquiry. If the old accounts close as paid and you repay the new loan on time, the effect is usually positive over time. Settlement is what hurts.
Can I consolidate credit card debt with a personal loan?
Yes, and it's often where consolidation saves most, because card interest is high. Keep the new tenure short.
Is a lower EMI always better?
No. A lower EMI from a longer tenure usually means more interest in total. Compare totals, not EMIs.
What to do next
Check your eligibility · Debt consolidation loans · Balance transfer calculator · How existing EMIs affect what you can borrow
CrediVitt is not a lender. Loans are provided by RBI-regulated banks and NBFCs, at their sole discretion.